For many homeowners in British Columbia, the choice comes down to two classics: cedar shake and asphalt shingle. Each has a proud history and a strong following in the Lower Mainland, and each brings distinct strengths and challenges. Deciding between them is about matching the right material to your home, your budget, and your tolerance for maintenance.
At RoofUpkeep.com, we work with roofs of every material across Metro Vancouver. Here is an honest comparison of cedar shake and asphalt shingle to help you make an informed decision.
Cedar Shake: Beauty with a Cost
Cedar shake roofs are an icon of the Pacific Northwest. Their natural, warm appearance suits many West Coast homes beautifully, and cedar can age gracefully when cared for.
The Appeal of Cedar
- Stunning aesthetics that many homeowners find unmatched
- Natural insulation, helping regulate attic temperatures
- A material that can last a long time in the right conditions
The Reality of Cedar in BC
Here is the honest side of cedar, especially in our wet climate:
- High maintenance. Cedar is vulnerable to moss, algae, and rot in the constant damp of the Lower Mainland. It typically requires regular treatment, cleaning, and moss removal to perform well.
- Preventative treatment is essential. Many cedar roofs in BC are installed with fire-retardant treatment, which can wear off over time and require re-application.
- Cost. Quality cedar shakes are generally more expensive than standard asphalt shingles, both in materials and installation.
- Splitting and curling. Over time, cedar can split and curl, especially under repeated wetting and drying cycles.
For cedar to live up to its potential here, it demands ongoing attention. Professional moss removal and regular inspections are not optional extras — they are part of owning a cedar roof.
Asphalt Shingle: Practical and Proven
Asphalt shingles are the most widely used roofing material across Canada, and it is easy to understand why.
The Appeal of Asphalt
- Affordable compared to most premium materials
- Wide range of styles and colours, including options that mimic wood and slate
- Easy to repair — individual damaged shingles can often be replaced quickly
- Lower maintenance than cedar in our climate, though not maintenance-free
The Reality of Asphalt
- Shorter lifespan than a well-maintained cedar roof, generally
- Susceptible to granule loss, curling, and cracking as it ages
- Still affected by moss and algae growth in shaded, damp areas
Cedar vs. Asphalt: A Side-by-Side Look
| Factor | Cedar Shake | Asphalt Shingle | | — | — | — | | Appearance | Natural, classic West Coast | Wide variety; can mimic other materials | | Upfront cost | Generally higher | Generally lower | | Lifespan potential | Long, with diligent care | Moderate to long depending on quality | | Maintenance | High in BC’s wet climate | Moderate | | Copper/pest/rot risk | Yes, if neglected | Lower | | Easy to repair | More involved | Relatively straightforward |
Which Is Right for Your Home?
There is no universal winner — only the right fit for your situation.
- Choose cedar if the aesthetic matters deeply to you, you plan to stay long-term, and you are prepared for the ongoing maintenance and cost it requires in our climate.
- Choose asphalt if you value affordability, ease of repair, and lower day-to-day maintenance, and if wood’s appearance is not a priority.
The Role of Care in Both
It is worth repeating: in the Lower Mainland, care makes a huge difference for both materials. A well-maintained asphalt roof can outperform a neglected cedar roof — and vice versa. Moss removal, debris cleaning, gutter maintenance, and regular professional inspections are the difference makers regardless of what sits on your roof.
Make the Best Choice with Help You Can Trust
Deciding between cedar and asphalt — or simply caring for the roof you already have — does not have to be guesswork. An honest assessment of your home, your budget, and your roof’s current condition goes a long way.
RoofUpkeep.com serves homeowners throughout Metro Vancouver and the Lower Mainland, including New Westminster, Burnaby, Coquitlam, Port Moody, Surrey, Vancouver, Richmond, Delta, and Langley. Whether your roof is cedar, asphalt, or something else, we can help you maintain it and plan for the future.
Comparing roofing options or caring for your current roof? Get your free quote at https://roofupkeep.com/#quote or call +1-778-513-7503. We are here to help you protect your home with honest, professional guidance.